The Moment I Knew We’d Messed Up
A few years back, one of my marcomms friends who operates their own agency in another state worked with a startup that sold “all-natural” skincare. Their product was great—until a customer found a synthetic preservative buried in the ingredient list.
The founder panicked. “Just tell them it’s a typo!” she said. Instead, my friend posted this: “We messed up. Here’s the preservative we used, why we used it, and how we’re reformulating.”
Sales dipped for a week. Then something wild happened: Loyal customers started defending the brand online. “They owned up—that’s rare,” one tweeted.
Moral of the story? Hiding the truth hurts more than the truth itself.
Why Transparency Isn’t Optional Anymore
Your audience isn’t stupid. They’ve seen greenwashing, fake reviews, and hidden fees. They've felt the sting of supporting a business who repeatedly asked for their help under false pretences. They’re tired of it.
Here’s what happens when you’re NOT transparent:
You lose trust (fast): 65% of consumers ditch brands that aren’t honest (Sprout Social, 2023).
You fuel rumors: Silence = guilt. Remember when Volkswagen tried to hide emissions fraud? It cost them $30 billion—and their reputation.
You miss loyalty opportunities: Patagonia’s “Don’t Buy This Jacket” campaign (which urged sustainable consumption) boosted sales by 30%. Why? Brutal honesty.
How to Be Transparent (Without Oversharing)
1. Ditch the “Perfect” Facade
Customers connect with humans, not logos.
Bad Example: A fitness brand photoshopping “perfect” bodies in ads.Better Example: Gymshark posting blooper reels of models tripping during shoots.
Your Move: Share a “behind-the-scenes” struggle this week. Did your product launch get delayed? Tell your audience why—don’t ghost them.
2. Turn Mistakes Into Momentum
When Airbnb faced discrimination claims, they didn’t hide. They released detailed reports on their progress—even when it was ugly.
Your Script for Screw-Ups:
“We messed up.”
“Here’s what happened.”
“Here’s how we’re fixing it.”
“Want to hold us accountable? Here’s how.”
3. Be Clear About What You Don’t Know
A client once asked me: “What if we can’t answer a question?”My reply: “Say, ‘We don’t know yet, but we’re working on it.’”
Example: When Chipotle’s app crashed during a promo, they tweeted: “We’re figuring out why the system broke. Updates soon. Free guac for your patience!”
The Fear Holding You Back
“But what if we look weak?”
Here’s the truth: Vulnerability is strength. A study by Cohn & Wolfe found 91% of consumers reward honest brands—even if they’re imperfect.
Case Study: A local bakery client accidentally used non-organic flour in their “100% organic” bread. Instead of hiding it, they:
Posted a video apology (with the head baker facepalming).
Offered refunds and free organic baking classes.
Sales doubled in a month. “We wanted to support their honesty,” one Yelp review said.
Your Homework
Run a “Transparency Audit”:
Check your website: Are there hidden fees, vague claims, or stock photos pretending to be your team?
Read customer reviews: What’s the #1 complaint you’re avoiding? Address it publicly.
Post One Uncomfortable Truth This Week:
Example: “Our ‘eco-friendly’ packaging isn’t perfect. Here’s why—and what we’re doing next.”
Reward Honesty:
Train your team to say “I don’t know” instead of bluffing.
Final Takeaway
Transparency isn’t about confessing sins. It’s about building a tribe that trusts you—even when you stumble.
So, what’s your brand hiding?
Need Help?If your marketing feels like a house of cards, let’s build something real. Together.
Comments